Break the Rules!!

I found a 78 year old man with a very strong balance sheet, but poor P&L account!

What does it mean?

Well he had a lot of assets – a nice big house which he was not using much, equities, bonds, and of course cash.

Life long if you (and me) are brought up saying ‘You will live within your means’ – we tend to interpret it as ‘though shall NEVER dip into your capital.

A fantastic thought process for sure, AND RIGHT TOO.

However when you are 78 years of age, YOU NEED TO BREAK THAT LAW….

Let us assume he has Rs. 30 lakhs in equities, Rs. 50 lakhs in bonds, post office, bank fd, etc. He also has a house which is worth Rs. 2 + crore. Son settled in US no chance of coming to India, doing well does not need this money.

This man has annual expenses of about Rs. 4 lakhs – which is ‘tight’ from his interest and dividend incomes!

He does not like the idea of selling some of his equities and converting it to bonds or bond fund – because he is emotionally ‘attached’ to those shares. So what can he do? live more frugally! He will be in a hurry to switch off the lights, will keep nagging his wife for switching on the fan in one room and going to get something, not go for a medical check up (oops can u beat that?), …

I suggested shifting about Rs. 25 lakhs to a variety of debt funds. This 25 to come from selling some equities, liquidating some FDs. He asked me ‘how much will be the dividend’ I said ‘not dividends would suggest a swp on a monthly basis.

He said ‘OMG it will come out of capital.

I said hardly. Given the current interest rates, if you do withdraw 1% pm it will take 30 years for the corpus to get over…..

I shudder to think what would have happened if I had suggested a Reverse Mortgage….

Related Articles:

Post Footer automatically generated by Add Post Footer Plugin for wordpress.

4 Responses to “Break the Rules!!”

  1. he probably feels no need to do anything since he never felt short of anything really having a sizable corpus which he believes will not extinguish in his lifetime. He has built tremendous inertia to spend beyond what he considers his means.
    O

  2. Subra -ji

    have a look at my comment in your post “sip works even in a bear market…”

    Kindly suggest where am i going wrong (if poss)

  3. I can understand… very difficult to change a mindset one has lived by all one’s life.

  4. May be he is enjoying his frugality; it is quite possible.

    But nagging his wife! She has equal right to this big corpus. He could not have practiced all this frugality unless she had managed household expenses frugally.

    At this age I think she has right to do what she wants. She wants to waste some electricity, so be it! She has earned it.

Leave a Reply

This blog is kept spam free by WP-SpamFree.