Every news paper and other media houses HAVE to do a story on ‘falling’ interest rates. Amusing. None of them will talk about ‘rising or constant’ REAL INTEREST rates!

(1)   The interest rates have seen a fall in recent times. Where do you see interest rates heading over the next one to two years?

The interest rates have fallen in recent times, does not mean we should call this as ‘falling interest times’. As more and more people get smarter and move money away from banks, banks will find that they do not have enough money to lend. They will stop buying government securities, and so the interest rates for the government will go up. If the economy grows at 9% for 3 years, there will be a huge demand for working capital and capital expansion. This will push interest rates up. I frankly do not know where the interest rates will be 2 years from now. Over the next one year it could fall by 100 basis points. 100 basis points is 1%. This is not too much.

(2)   Senior citizens and other who are dependent on fixed income products will see their incomes reduce in the coming months. What options do they have for investments if they wish to maintain their income levels?

Senior citizens and others who are dependent on fixed income products should understand that since the combo of RR and NaMo have been operating, REAL INTEREST has been going UP, not down. Real interest is “Nominal Interest MINUS  Inflation”. So the senior citizens should not do chest beating about falling interest rates, they should be rejoicing about rising REAL INTEREST rates. Asset allocation should not change because interest rate changes. However, senior citizens are well protected with a 9% interest in Senior Citizens Saving Scheme and of course the Public Provident fund. If they had invested in bond funds (or bonds instead of fixed deposits) their portfolio would appreciate and they could sell off some of the bonds. The interest rates on fixed bonds would be fixed and they would have got 9 or 9.6% interest when the interest rates are falling in newer instruments.

(3)  Going forward what kind of returns can they expect from the other investments?

This is a good question, and I have no answer. Talking of ‘expected’ returns from equity or real estate is naive. A short term number to these asset classes makes no sense.

(4)   Does the move push the ultra-cautious investor into the risky market of equity investments to maintain his or her income levels?

Cannot comment on this as long as people do not understand the difference between long term risk (inflation) and short term risk (volatility). So for a person who thinks equity is risky, he should be in debt and for a person like me who thinks debt is risky, I remain in equity. Touche’.

 

  1. Inflation is reducing on paper.
    However actually if you see retail inflation is continuously increasing. So even real return is reducing.

    Tough times for people who rely only on FDs.

  2. It’s strange, government RR keeps on talking of falling CPI, in my family budget we still find difficult to meet. The spends which only rise are : medical, Education,entertainment telephone,cable,household help, utilities. These makeup 75% of our expenses.
    Anyone with similar experience? Subbu your considered comments please.

  3. Inflation numbers or CPI is a basket of products and services used by a common man. Mine or your consumption basket can be somewhat or vastly different than the typical basket as prepared by CSO/Fin Min.
    But nonetheless, inflation is falling and it is visible and therefore real interest rate is constant/rising – no doubt on that.

  4. Subra sir,
    I have gone through the article you shared and you have correctly summarised importance of tracking expenses. But cost of basic living is also increasing rapidly.
    Only option that remains is to have equity exposure for salaried person who dont have any ancestral wealth.

  5. Conman man on the street would laugh if you ask whether inflation is is going down

    1. Real estate rents up
    2 School / Education fees up
    3. Eatables up
    4. Personal servants/bais salary up (more than inflation)
    5. Holidaying taxes, entertainment eating out alcohol all are up

    What more can a common man consume, there is not a single item in the consumable basket which has fallen (or risen less sharply than last year or year before that or even before)

  6. Koustubh Chakraborty

    The inflation rate as announced officially seems to be a number plucked out of thin air, malleable as per the government’s whims. Perhaps, it is the inflation on the price of Idli-Vada in the parliament’s subsidized canteen that’s showing signs of coming down.

    IITs raise their tuition fees by 122 %, the other colleges following suit. 3rd Party Vehicle Insurance suddenly jumps by 40 %. The service tax imposed on everything-under-the-sun increases from 12.36 % to 14 % ( 13.67 % increase). Yet the govt, the paid media and few websites tom-tom that inflation’s reached to sub-5% levels !! Based on that, RBI lowers its interest rates…………..pockets long empty, the common man has to dig into his savings to meet everyday expenses.

    It seems in 2019, like in 2004, the NDA (and the media alike ) will still be wondering what hit them — so disconnected from reality they’ve become.

  7. You are not entirely right Umang. Look at some of the other costs. TV costs have remained in a range in the last 20 years. So have an average mobile phone rates. Car rates too are broadly not very different than they were 15 years back. Potato were at Rs 60 two years back and are Rs 20 now. Onions were Rs. 100 and are Rs 20 now. There are many such things as well. the overall basket thus needs to be seen to get full view.

  8. Dear umang, k chakraborty, Globally product prices are falling, look at commodity index, all prices are 5-6 yrlow, agricultural prices till 2 months back were 3-4-6 yr lows, why did not the Indian consumers get benefit of it? Did prices of cookers, utensils, steel furniture come down to 5 yr low. No.. Our Distribution channel’s are too entrenched. With multiple leak points. Customer centric orientation is too low.

  9. Does the inflation calculation includes the effect of taxes? (services tax / excise duty etc…) Or Does the calculation excludes it?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes:

<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>